Whether you’re craving for wood-fired bubbles, sourdough tang or crispy edges, Columbus offers a selection of real pizza spots that promise to satisfy every palate.
Columbus’s real pizza guide curates the city’s standout pizzerias, each offering a unique slice of heaven.
Johnny’s New York Style Pizza
9/10 (1158 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-507-5050
Fresh doughGenerous toppingsFriendly staff
Johnny’s New York Style Pizza is a hidden gem in the area, serving up fresh and delicious pizzas that are definitely worth the cost. The dough is fresh, the toppings are generous, and the food is packed with flavor. The staff is accommodating and takes pride in their food, evident in the quality and taste of the pizzas. While there might be occasional issues with orders or wait times, the friendly service and incredible food more than make up for it. The pizza here is the star of the show, but other menu items like the garlic knots are also solid choices. If you’re looking for authentic New York style pizza with a local touch, Johnny’s is the place to be.
Your Pie Pizza
9/10 (1044 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-221-6899
Friendly staffUnique pizza optionsOne-price, customizable toppings
This downtown pizza spot is a gem with friendly staff and fast service. The pizza is light and delicious, complemented by a great beer selection on tap. Finding parking is easy too. The food is consistently delicious, with fresh and unique pizza options. My personal favorite was the seasonal Peach Prosciutto Pizza, a surprisingly delicious combo of flavors. The one-price, choose-your-toppings concept is a winner, making it a great spot to visit again and again.
Pizza Pronto
8.8/10 (241 reviews)
| Directions | +1 706-596-9855
Affordable large pizzasDelicious thin crustHidden gem location
Nestled in a small strip mall on the far north side of Columbus, Pizza Pronto may not seem like much at first glance. But don’t let the exterior fool you – this hidden gem is a must-try for pizza lovers. For just $7, you can indulge in a large 1-topping pizza that is both delicious and affordable. The thin crust allows the quality toppings and exquisite sauce to truly shine, making every bite a delightful experience. With a 95 on their Health Department inspection, this spot is a safe bet for a scrumptious meal that won’t break the bank. If you’re in the mood for a tasty slice of pizza, Pizza Pronto is the place to go.
Ramos italian restaurant and social event center
8.6/10 (80 reviews)
| Directions | +1 762-524-7356
Exceptional serviceFlavorful dishesPleasant atmosphere
Ramos italian restaurant and social event center offers exceptional service with delicious dishes, such as perfectly cooked lasagna, flavorful garlic bread, and fresh salads. The atmosphere, with dim lighting and the option to add extra seasonings like oregano and red pepper flakes, sets the stage for a pleasant dining experience. While there may be some minor issues to address, like food temperature and tea quality, overall Ramos italian restaurant and social event center is a must-try spot for those craving Italian cuisine.
Mellow Mushroom Columbus
8.8/10 (1103 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-322-4602
Delicious made-to-order pizzasUnique and inviting atmosphereFriendly and efficient staff
Mellow Mushroom Columbus is a must-visit for those seeking a unique dining experience. The restaurant offers a great selection of made-to-order pizzas and a variety of refreshing drinks to pair with your meal. The atmosphere is inviting, with beautiful artwork on the walls that transport you to a whimsical world. The prices are reasonable for the quality you receive, making it a great option for a family dinner or lunch with friends. The food is flavorful and fresh, and the staff works hard to ensure a clean environment. While there may be some inconsistencies in service, the overall experience at Mellow Mushroom Columbus is worth a visit.
Rising Flour Pizza
9.2/10 (183 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-561-8778
Fresh toppingsCozy atmosphereFriendly service
Rising Flour Pizza is a gem worth discovering. The Specialty 9 toppings Pizza is a standout menu item that is fresh and flavorful. The cozy atmosphere and reasonable prices make it a great dining spot for any occasion. The friendly service is an added bonus that ensures a pleasant dining experience. The true highlight, however, is the perfect balance of toppings on the pizza, making it a must-try for pizza lovers looking for a new favorite spot!
Your Pie Pizza
8.8/10 (635 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-507-1743
Customizable pizzasFriendly and helpful staffQuick service
Your Pie Pizza offers a unique experience where you can customize your own pizza with fresh ingredients. The staff is incredibly friendly and helpful, guiding you through the process with a welcoming attitude. The food is top-notch, with delicious options for both traditional and vegan pizzas. The quick service and affordable prices make it a great spot for families or individuals looking for a quality meal. Plus, the extensive topping options allow you to create a personalized pizza that suits your taste perfectly. From the moment you walk in, you can feel the warmth and care put into each pizza, making it a standout dining experience.
Cerrone’s Brick Oven Pizzeria – Pizza Restaurant | Pizza
9.2/10 (809 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-221-2778
Delicious, fresh pizzaExcellent customer serviceCozy atmosphere
Cerrone’s Brick Oven Pizzeria stands out as a top-notch pizza joint, offering a variety of delicious pies and appetizers that go beyond the standard fare. The helpful staff guides diners in choosing the perfect pizza and provides excellent customer service. The fresh, hot pizzas impress with their light, airy crusts, fresh toppings, and flavorful cheese and sauce. The cozy atmosphere and nice beer selection enhance the overall dining experience.
Mr. Pizza Brick Oven and Tap
8.6/10 (457 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-507-0483
Delicious thin crustFriendly staffComfortable atmosphere
Mr. Pizza Brick Oven and Tap offers a delicious experience that customers rave about. From the best thin crust pizzas to the Pig Farm pie with original crust, the food is a standout. The Brickhouse salad with homemade balsamic dressing is a must-try, paired perfectly with a side of homemade marinara. The ice-cold beers and pleasant atmosphere create the ideal setting for a casual meal. The friendly staff, including standout servers like Sara(h), add to the enjoyable dining experience. While some menu items may be unavailable, the overall experience at Mr. Pizza Brick Oven and Tap is one that will keep customers coming back for more.
My Boulánge & Tower Pizza
9.2/10 (683 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 706-940-0112
Thin crust pizzasMade-to-order sandwichesComfortable atmosphere
Nestled in the heart of the city, My Boulánge & Tower Pizza is a hidden gem that offers a delightful experience. The thin crust pizzas are a standout, perfectly balanced with toppings that will leave you satisfied without feeling weighed down. The made-to-order sandwiches are a must-try, with fresh bread that elevates each bite. Despite some minor hiccups in service, the inviting atmosphere and top-notch coffee make this cafe a destination worth visiting.
Peluso’s Italian Restaurant
8.6/10 (246 reviews)
| Directions | +1 706-324-5888
Deep dish pizzaFriendly staffOld-school charm
Peluso’s Italian Restaurant may not catch your eye from the outside, but once inside, you’ll find a charming, old-school Italian eatery that serves up delicious, hearty dishes. The deep dish pizza is a must-try, loaded with generous toppings that pack a flavorful punch. The friendly staff adds to the welcoming atmosphere, making it a great spot for a casual meal with family or friends.
Blondies Sports
8.6/10 (711 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 212-362-3311
Lively atmosphereStellar wingsTop-notch service
Blondies Sports is a beloved establishment in the Upper West Side, drawing in a crowd of sports enthusiasts and foodies alike. The atmosphere is lively, especially during game days, making it the perfect spot to catch a live sporting event. The wings here are a standout, with a perfect balance of crispiness and sauciness that keeps customers coming back for more. The bar staff, including Jill and Denny, provide top-notch service that adds to the overall excellent experience at Blondies Sports.
Cheeseboat Hell’s Kitchen
9.6/10 (426 reviews)
Website | Directions | +1 646-684-4214
Traditional cheese boatKhinkali soup dumplingsCozy atmosphere
Cheeseboat Hell’s Kitchen is a delightful find in the heart of Manhattan. The traditional cheese boat shines as the star of the meal – the outstanding bread paired with delicious cheese creates a fun and filling dining experience. The khinkali soup dumplings offer a unique and juicy taste, while the green sauce adds a flavorful touch to the meal. The cozy atmosphere and attentive service make Cheeseboat a must-visit spot in Hell’s Kitchen for those looking to explore the flavors of Georgian cuisine.